Review: Women of the Republic, by Linda Kerber

9780393303452-usWomen of the Republic: Intellect and Ideology in Revolutionary America
by Linda Kerber
The University of North Carolina Press, 1997

Frequently if not ubiquitously cited in later studies of women in the Revolutionary era, Women of the Republic holds up in many significant ways to its reputation. Kerber combs through first-hand records—files, letters, documents—to glean information about and, most interestingly, quotes from late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century American women to give a glimpse into their private and political lives. Not merely a documentary record, however, Kerber unites her primary sources under subject-specific chapters and knits them together with both insight and theory.

Kerber is equally interested in the theoretical and the everyday, and the mix of the two lends the book a roundedness, since it doesn’t have to live in either realm—something that’s often stifling to women’s history, or any history—but considers and draws from both. The chapter on women in Enlightenment literature, drawing from hefty philosophical texts, is just as engaging as the chapter on divorce, drawing on municipal documents and diary entries, is just as interesting as the chapter on women’s education, which draws on everything from letters to newspapers to more theoretical texts. Together this wealth of sources come together to create a cohesive look at women’s experiences in the early Republic.

Or rather, some women’s experiences in the early Republic—though Kerber is able to include information on middle and lower-class women, at least through official records if not the letters and diaries she uses for upper-class women, Women of the Republic is devoid of evidence of any women who weren’t white. There are only the most oblique of references to anyone at all who might not be white, alluding only in passing to nameless and narrative-less slaves. Race seems not to be a concern in the book, as it labors under the implicit notion that only white women—only white people—exist at all. Native Americans get not even a mention. (more…)


Eliza Bowen Jumel

13-lithograph-of-eliza-smallEliza Jumel (April 2, 1775 – July 16, 1865), born into poverty, made her way up the social ladder until she was one of the richest women in New York. Born Betsey Bowen in Providence, Rhode Island, on the eve of the Revolutionary War, Jumel lived in brothels and workhouses throughout her childhood, eventually becoming indentured to a sea captain and his wife. By 1798 both her parents were dead, and the young and ambitious Jumel moved to New York City, when she became an extra in the local theater and worked various jobs as a domestic servant. Several years later, she met the wealthy Stephen Jumel, and they soon married. The house they moved into as their summer home, and the house Jumel would live in in her later life, is preserved today as a historic site, the Morris-Jumel Mansion.

In 1815 the Jumels sailed for France, where Stephen had been born and lived until he was a young man, before emigrating to America. The couple stayed in Paris for a time, but the next year Eliza sailed back to America, while Stephen remained in France. While apart, Eliza managed several of Stephen’s real estate interests with noted business acumen. The couple continued to travel between France and America, sometimes together and sometimes apart. During these travels Eliza amassed a large European art collection, which she brough back to America to great fanfare.

Stephen Jumel died in 1832; shortly thereafter Eliza remarried former vice president Aaron Burr. The match was socially advantages for her and financially advantages for the broke Burr: however, they soon separated and soon after divorced. Jumel lived for another thirty years, continuing to mantain her great estate, and later adopting her great-niece and -nephew, children of her sister. She died in 1865, and was buried in Trinity Churchyard in Manhatten.

Learn more on Wikipedia

(Eliza Bowen Jumel’s Wikipedia page had been extensively edited recently by the RWP. If you have anything to add to it, go ahead!)


Review: Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings, by Annette Gordon-Reed

51HCaWoSesL._SY344_BO1,204,203,200_Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings: An American Controversy
by Annette Gordon-Reed
University of Virginia Press, 1997

Gordon-Reed makes explicit at the beginning of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings that she is not trying to prove that they had a sexual relationship. The book was released a year before the DNA test results that convinced even many skeptics of the idea, and at the time Gordon-Reed was writing there were few, at least in academic circles, that believed that Jefferson could have fathered Hemings’s children.

Despite this, however, Gordon-Reed makes a strong case for the plausibility of the relationship. She focuses primarily on inspecting what previous Jefferson historians have said on the subject, the evidence they’ve used, and the methods by which they’ve come to their near-universal conclusion that the relationship was in no way possible—and finds them on all counts severely lacking. In a methodical style that’s saved from tedium by her dry, often cutting wit, Gordon-Reed examines the way the discussion of Jefferson and Hemings had progressed through the years, pointing out the ways in which the evidence has been twisted by historians to defend Jefferson against the charge of miscegenation.

Take for example one of the most astute and convincing portions of the book, the discussion of the memoirs of Madison Hemings, Sally Hemings’s son, and of the statements of Thomas Jefferson Randolph, Jefferson’s grandson. Gordon-Reed demonstrates that the way historians have framed these two pieces of evidence—Hemings’s statement that Jefferson was his father, Randolph’s statement that Jefferson was not—is both blatantly racist and, because of this, just as blatantly inaccurate. Historians have characterized Madison Hemings negatively to establish him as an unreliable narrator, while at the same time implying Randolph is a trustworthy and reliable source.

Gordon-Reed demonstrates, however, that many of Hemings’s statements can be corroborated by other sources (and Hemings’s descriptions of Monticello are in fact used by historians as trustworthy descriptions of what life was like there), while Randolph’s statements are at their heart not factually true. (Randolph claims that his mother, Martha Jefferson Randolph, told him that Jefferson could not have fathered Sally Hemings’s children because he was not at Monticello when they would’ve been conceived. Thanks to Jefferson scholar Dumas Malone’s exhaustive timeline of Jefferson’s whereabouts during most of his adult life, we know that Jefferson was in fact at Monticello nine months before each of Hemings’s children was born.) “It is a strange turn of events,” Gordon-Reed says dryly, “when individuals who held other human beings in bondage are given presumptive moral superiority over their captives.” (more…)


Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton

Mrs._Elizabeth_Schuyler_HamiltonElizabeth Schuyler Hamilton (August 9, 1757-November 9, 1854) was the co-founder and longtime directress of the New York Orphan Asylum Society and the wife of Alexander Hamilton. Born into the wealthy and influential Schuyler family, she was the second of eight surviving children. Hamilton was a friend of Martha Washington’s, as well as many other well-known women of her day. She married Alexander Hamilton in 1780, and they would ultimately have eight children together. Their marriage lasted twenty-four years, despite his admitted infidelity with another woman, ending only with his untimely death in the infamous duel with Aaron Burr.

After her husband’s death Hamilton remained dedicated to preserving his legacy, working to ensure his biography would be written and establishing his authorship of Washington’s Farewell Address. In addition, she helped to found the Orphan Asylum Society in 1806, and, first as second directress and later as first directress, oversaw the construction of a children’s orphanage as well as a school she founded in Upper Manhattan. She lived to the age of ninety-seven, having retained her role as first directress of the OAS until only six years before her death.

Learn more on Wikipedia.

(Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton’s Wikipedia page had been extensively edited recently by the RWP. If you have anything to add to it, go ahead!)